Hello.
The first revision of this post appears after the jump, it remains to provide context for the comment left by Fadingstar86. Swathes of it will appear in this hopefully more articulate version.
This post was prompted by something I read recently. It should when finished be something I wish I had read before I started self-harming or soon after. It could also very well be just an opinion I have, an erroneous one too, but maybe I am right, or maybe I will be just about onto something
A couple of nights ago I read a post that talked about how someone started self-harming, at some point in that post it referred to self harm as a method of coping and that bothered me.
Self-harm stories are similar to urban legends in that they are almost all the same with a variance in detail. I don’t wish to minimise the importance of someone self-harming, at the most basic it is central to them, it can affect relationships and many other things but it is not special. The stories almost always start after a period of time of feeling miserable or stressed or having something seemingly insurmountable to deal with (though sometimes it is a particular intense bout of emotion) followed by an accidental or unknowing act of hurting yourself that brings some relief (frequent bringing feeling where there had been nothing or bringing a more desirable feeling) then a deliberate and knowing act that produces the same effect and then it happens again and again. The story is not uncommon, my story is embellished a little by my introduction to it by a friend though I am certain I am not the only person who knew a friend who did it before they started, statistics support this.
For a very long time, seven or so years, I self-harmed and though I talk about it although it is in the past, the scars are very present, I still have a months old wound that is still healing up, and perhaps more concerningly I cannot say with any real certainty I will not do it again, I certainly think about doing it. Largely though I believe that those things are behind me.
I never really discussed what self-harm was to me with anyone until I started writing this blog. People knew but largely, and most often correctly, it was my depressive thoughts that were discussed. I never really had a language for talking about it but when the language developed I am sure that referred to it as a coping mechanism. I want to call bullshit on self-harm as a coping mechanism because it is not helpful.
Saying it isn’t helpful is a hard pill for even me to swallow. Last night I was struggling to sleep and I knew that if I made a small cut the relaxing relief washing over me would help me to sleep. It is helpful in the short term, the very short term but largely it isn’t. This short term help makes me reluctant to call it a coping mechanism, self-harm did not let me cope with things, it allowed me to limp on a bit whilst the thing was still there. I believe this to be true of all self-harmers, I cannot believe that one incident or brief episode of self-harm provides anyone with the ability to cope with something, it may do something else but we will come to that.
Calling it a coping mechanism does not make it right or good. I read in a book someone say that cutting their wrists was not to make them die but to let them live, that it was an anti-suicide. I can understand that, I have used self-harm to stave off suicidal thoughts that I would have acted on, landing myself in A and E for sutures is better than landing myself in a coffin but it does not make trips to A and E okay, or cutting myself at all okay, or any other form of self harm okay. Calling self-harm a coping mechanism feels like a way of excusing the inexcusable.
I stubbed my toe recently and it hurt a lot, it didn’t bring relief or any of the other feelings associated with when I self harm. It is not the hurt itself that brings the relief it is the reaction to it that brings it and that reaction is all in the head. There is a physical component, no doubt, but the reaction and the relief comes from your head not the hurt. Your body is actively telling you that it is wrong, it used to hurt like hell when I removed the adhesive dressings that I dressed wounds with, but your mind is telling you otherwise.
I cannot, and I am willing to be proved wrong, think of an instance when self-harm would be the only appropriate course of action. It may be the path of least resistance but it is not the only path, there are other ways to deal with things, to cope with things.
Your life is yours, it might not be perfect but it is yours, and you are responsible not for what happens to you but how you react to it. Peoples’ lives are often miserable and have shitty things happen and the sad truth is that it is par for the course. I can completely understand why people turn to self-harm, I did for years, but it never stopped me being miserable or the shitty things from happening. The best self-harm offered was a mask.
Those increasingly short periods where the miserable, stressful, horrible things in my life were masked were excellent. But to need and require that masking is asking for trouble, at the peak of my self harming I was cutting 7 or 8 times a day just to maintain a level where things felt bearable. But those multiple cuttings never once stopped the miserable, stressful, horrible things being real and present. The best I can see self-harm offering is a way to ignore and distract yourself from whatever shit it is you want to be distracted from long enough for it to go away. And this isn’t coping in the truest sense, that is scraping by.
Perhaps I am confusing coping with and dealing with, I largely believe these are the same things.
The really insidous and hideous thing about self-harm is that it hard-wires itself into your brain as a reaction to bad things happening. You may very well end up requiring it for things that are not as bad as the thing that came before. All that time spent waiting for the bad thing to go away is just training yourself to rely on self-harm. Relying on self-harm sucks.
Cutting my arm when I was horribly depressed didn’t make me less depressed, it just brought another emotion to the front for a time and then it went back to being depressed with the added kicker of a bleeding wound. Self-harm in this way leads to a downward spiral – depressed, cut, relief, guilt, depressed, cut, relief, guilt and so on. It is similar to alcoholism and drug abuse in this way, the desired effect is ever decreasing with the initial problem remaining untouched.
I don’t think I will ever be a happy person, I don’t think I have it in me, but I am damned sure that things can be better than this and I am also damned sure that self-harm has never contributed positively to my life. I recognise and freely admit that it let me get through tough times but it has left me covered in hundreds of scars that make me feel sad. All those times I was close to suicide or feeling overwhelmed it would have been much much better to do something other than self-harm. As I said before I cannot think that a single occasion could exist when self-harm is the only answer.
Self-harm was the answer for me because I didn’t feel strong enough to tackle something that felt, feels insurmountable and more than anything I didn’t want to share how screwed up and horrid and painful those thoughts were.
But taking the more difficult path ultimately is more helpful.
I stopped self-harming gradually, really gradually. So deeply ingrained was it as a behavior it had to be tackled before anything else could. The self-harm made me too unstable to treat. It took months to get the self-harm to a manageable level, the sort of level where I could deal with the underlying shit that was causing me to self-harm.
Only now, and very loosely, am I coping. I am coping in that I am recognising how big this illness is and how much time I will need to treat it. I still want to be free from this and quickest way is suicide but I am willing to stick it out and increase the deadline a little and that feels like coping. Coping for me involves a lot of medication, weekly therapy and doing not much else. Self-harm would just mask the horrible stuff for awhile and right now I’d prefer to have it not masked than be visiting A and E again.
I can only see self-harm as a bad thing.
Dealing with self-harm is easier said than done, I know, but it is really just a two, albeit broad, stepped process.
- Find a way to deal with the urge to self harm, there are websites full of these distraction techniques, go look them up.
- Once you have had a significant, and that is your call, period free of self-harm get to work on whatever it was that made you want to self-harm.
Most simplisticly, ask for help, get it sorted. Your life is yours, it may have shitty things happen to it so don’t add to that yourself.
Have at it.
jump
Keep reading →